Culantro vs cilantro vs coriander or parsley: how to tell them apart
Learn how to tell culantro, cilantro, coriander and parsley apart by leaf shape, aroma and use in Thai cooking, with clear answers to what each herb is.
Contents
- Start with the leaf edges
- Crush a leaf and smell it
- Why coriander confuses everyone
- Questions about culantro, cilantro and parsley
- Is culantro the same as cilantro?
- What is the difference between culantro and cilantro?
- Can I use parsley instead of cilantro or culantro?
- How do I recognize culantro in a Thai market?
Culantro, cilantro, coriander and parsley are four different plants that shoppers often confuse, and this page shows how to tell them apart. You will learn the leaf shapes to look for, the smells that give each one away, and why Thai cooking keeps culantro and cilantro on separate shelves. Coriander names the same plant as cilantro in much of the world, so the word itself is part of the puzzle. Parsley sits outside that family entirely and looks similar only from a distance.
Start with the leaf edges
Leaf shape separates these herbs faster than any other clue in the market. Cilantro and flat-leaf parsley carry broad, flat leaflets with soft, rounded edges and a pointed tip. Culantro, known to botanists as Eryngium foetidum, grows long leaves with sharp sawtooth edges, which is why cooks call it sawtooth herb. Curly parsley adds a frilled edge that no other herb here shares.
Crush a leaf and smell it
Aroma settles the identification when the leaves look alike, so crush one small leaf between your fingers. Cilantro, Coriandrum sativum, releases a sharp, green scent that some eaters describe as soapy. Culantro carries a much stronger version of that same cilantro smell, and a single leaf flavors a whole pot. Flat-leaf parsley smells grassy and mild, with none of the citrus note that cilantro gives off.
Why coriander confuses everyone
Coriander and cilantro name the same plant, Coriandrum sativum, in different English-speaking regions. North American cooks say cilantro for the leaf and coriander for the dried seed, while British and Australian cooks call the leaf coriander. The seed tastes warm and citrusy, quite unlike the fresh leaf. Culantro remains a separate species, so no naming overlap links it to coriander.
Questions about culantro, cilantro and parsley
Is culantro the same as cilantro?
No, culantro and cilantro come from different plants even though their leaves smell alike. Culantro is Eryngium foetidum, a plant with long sawtooth leaves, and cilantro is the leaf of Coriandrum sativum. Culantro delivers a stronger aroma that survives long cooking, so Thai kitchens use it in soups and curries.
What is the difference between culantro and cilantro?
The leaf shape and the strength of the aroma separate culantro from cilantro. Culantro leaves grow long and narrow with serrated edges, while cilantro leaves are broad and soft-edged. Culantro also holds its flavor through heat, whereas cilantro loses much of its scent when cooked.
Can I use parsley instead of cilantro or culantro?
No, parsley cannot replace cilantro or culantro because it lacks their distinctive scent. Flat-leaf parsley, Petroselinum crispum, brings a mild grassy note that suits salads and sauces. A Thai recipe that calls for cilantro or culantro needs that specific green flavor, so parsley changes the dish.
How do I recognize culantro in a Thai market?
Culantro stands out in a Thai market by its long, stiff leaves with jagged sawtooth edges. The leaves fan out from a low rosette instead of growing on tall stems like cilantro. Crush a leaf edge and you get a powerful cilantro smell that confirms the sawtooth herb.